How Scentome works
Fragrances
Every fragrance on Scentome is sold by at least one of 27 shops in the US and Canada. Strengths of the same scent, such as Eau de Toilette and Parfum, are listed together, while a different line such as Sauvage Elixir has its own page. Notes are the ones the shop or brand lists for the fragrance.
Alternatives
An alternative is a fragrance people recommend as a stand-in for another, usually for less money. Scentome finds them in five places:
- Reddit posts and comments in r/fragranceclones and similar communities, 17,349 threads so far
- what 10 fragrance reviewers on YouTube say in their videos' titles and descriptions
- 7 community clone lists
- the maker's own description, when it names the fragrance it was inspired by
- shop descriptions that say the same
Each person counts once per pair, however often they mention it. Wording matters: "1:1" counts for more than "smells a bit like", and "nothing like it" counts against. Upvoted and recent comments count for more.
Each pair gets one of four verdicts:
- Clone
- At least six people across three threads, several of them calling it near-identical, plus a second kind of source such as a clone list, and very few people disagreeing.
- Close dupe
- At least three people across two threads recommend it as a substitute, and most people agree.
- Inspired by
- The maker says it was inspired by the original, or people mostly describe it as a take on it.
- Similar
- People compare the two, but not as a copy.
Fragrances from the same house are never listed as alternatives to each other. Each pair has a page with every comment and list entry behind it.
"Similar notes" on a fragrance page is a separate list: fragrances from other houses whose note lists overlap most with this one.
Which Reddit accounts count
Each account is checked against its Reddit history and what it has written in fragrance threads. An account is left out if it posts discount codes or promotions, pastes the same comment over and over, has the name of a house it recommends in its username, or recommends one house almost exclusively while posting almost nowhere else. An account that was less than 60 days old when it commented, or has under 20 karma, counts half.
Prices
Prices come from each shop's own site, for buyers in your country, in the currency the shop charges. Every price shown, on every page, was checked in the last half hour; a price that has not been checked since is not shown. Scentome checks the shops itself, every 20 minutes; looking at a page never sends a request to a shop. Sold-out sizes don't appear, and testers are labelled. Prices are sorted by price per millilitre. Some links to shops are affiliate links.
Updates
Prices are checked every 20 minutes. Four times a day, Scentome adds new fragrances and sizes from the shops, reads new Reddit posts and replies and the clone lists, and updates every verdict.